Oftentimes in a person’s everyday life, they are on camera: the camera on their phone, the dash cam in their car, the security camera as they walk in and out of a shopping centre. In a family law dispute, a person may seek to use their camera to record contacts with their former partner, they may record conversations with family members or friends, or record children before or after time with the other parent. While people may think they are acting protectively in a low conflict manner, there are risks that flow from secretly recording another person and using that recording.
In each state and territory in Australia, there are recording and surveillance laws. Some jurisdictions permit the use of recordings in certain circumstances. For example, in Queensland, a recording is legal if made with only one party’s consent. The person consenting to the recording can be the same person who takes the recording. In the Australian Capital Territory, however, there is no such exception. In the ACT, it is illegal to record another person without their consent, including an audio recording. It is also a criminal offence to transmit that recording, for example, providing it to family and friends, or to a lawyer for advice.
At its basic, this means that generally, it is illegal to record another person or retain such a recording, in the ACT. There are exceptions that apply in certain circumstances. The Court does not permit the use of such recordings, except in certain limited circumstances. Those circumstances may include where, notwithstanding the recording was made contrary to the relevant law, the desirability of admitting the recording into evidence before the Court outweighs the undesirability of admitting such evidence. In simple terms, the information obtained by a secret recording, and the relevance of that information to the circumstances of the particular case, may outweigh the issue of relying on a secret recording that was improperly obtained.
There is no hard and fast rule about the acceptance or rejection of secret recordings in family law. It is dependent on the circumstances of the case and the admissibility (or lack thereof) of the secret recordings. The Court is particularly critical of secret recordings where the evidence could be obtained by other means:
By the making of diary entries, on a note’s app or in hard copy, at the time of each incident or event;
By the making of complaints to police, counselling, domestic violence or child welfare services, which can later be obtained by Subpoena;
By making written contact with family, friends or services, where contacts can be later produced.
There are often other ways to gather evidence to support your position that is safe, respectful, and within the bounds of the law. If you intend to use recordings that you have, you should seek legal advice on whether or not these recordings can and should be used. To understand how the law applies to your particular circumstances, contact our office at (02) 6225 7040 or by email at info@rmfamilylaw.com.au or get started now online.